answer this question

Harry Potter Question

Isn't the whole concept of wizarding money self-contradictory?

In pg.65 of Chamber of Secrets,we see how Hermione's parents exchange Muggle money for Galleons.Now we also know that objects such as chairs can be Conjured(like Dumbledore does in the courtroom in HP and the Order of the Phoenix).These Conjured chairs and stuff can be sold to Muggle shops to obtain Muggle money,which can then be exchanged into Galleons.So now we see that any wizard who knows basic Transfiguration can earn an infinite amount of money.So what's the point of wizarding money in the first place?
 hunterkf5732 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

JungleQueen13 said:
There are possibly some rules in place to stop wizards from exchanging Muggle money (perhaps only Muggles or those from Muggle-born families are allowed to do it). There might also be laws against selling Transfigured items in Muggle shops. There could still be a way around such laws, but most wizards probably couldn't be bothered, and I can imagine pure-blood families like the Malfoys believing it was beneath them to associate with the Muggle world at all, even to make money.
It's an interesting thought though, and it would be nice to know more about the laws surrounding Transfiguration.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LiptonGold said:
Well, someone would probably catch them, also inflation

Maybe you're the first to think of this.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
I don't really see how someone could catch them since Transfiguration is not traceable.
hunterkf5732 posted over a year ago
*
Well, they'd just have absurd amounts of money and someone may ask where it's coming from. If the person amassed suspicion they could be investigated
LiptonGold posted over a year ago
*
the point is that once one person starts doing this,it would spread around and soon everyone'll be doing it.
hunterkf5732 posted over a year ago
*
Hmm, yeah, but then inflation kicks in. That or they run out of material to make more galleons to go around/refuse to do so
LiptonGold posted over a year ago
next question »