answer this question

Harry Potter Question

Is ancient magic more powerful that “modern” magic?

I always get the impression from the HP books(like in Lily’s case) and from other books about magic, that ancient magic (spells, potions etc) is much more powerful than today’s magic. What do you believe, and why?
Is ancient magic more powerful that “modern” magic?
*
Yes, but why in your opinion, it's more powerful?
Mallory23 posted over a year ago
 Mallory23 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

Irina92 said:
well yeah, of course ancient magic is more powerful than modern... and in this case i think that the fact that voldemort didn't know much bout it had a really important part in the story!
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Yes, but why it's more powerful?
Mallory23 posted over a year ago
*
coz it is based on stronger things, like love, honer... while modern magic is just for surface stuff and for people's needs... at least that's wa i think!
Irina92 posted over a year ago
*
hehe no prob! nice question anyway! :)
Irina92 posted over a year ago
Azhar9 said:
I believe the ANCIENT magic is more powerful than MODERN magic. You will find so many examples around you. Think about medicines. HERBEL & ANCIENT NATURAL medicines are much effective than modern PILLS.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
123hihihi said:
i would have 2 say ancient
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
LabraLege said:
Because wizards didn't waste their time on the things like Voldemort and had lots of time to think of something :)) that's just my opinion, but this question really interesting and confusing...
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
davven said:
I think that modern magic is more powerfull, after all they evolve their magic all the time and come up with new spells. But since much of the knowledge about ancient magic have been forgotten(by most) it appears more powerfull. If you don't have knowledge of a spell then you can't fight it and if you havn't considered the possibility of a spell it will appear more effective. Another way to see it is that the very few ancient spells we know of are the ones that havn't yet been surpassed by any newer spell. In that way to look at it these specific spells are in fact the most powerfull ones in thier cathegory. However, just because they are the best spells yet doesn't meen ancient magic is more powerfull in general, with only a few spells yet not outdone by modern ones it is definetly not. (for the football fans: Just like Pelé being the best player of all times doesn't make football from his era better than today's football)
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »