answer this question

Harry Potter Question

For hardcore HP fans out there: I have a mission for you :)

Okay, lately my friend told me that "Harry Potter fans are basically a cult." ... I had no idea what a cult was. So i looked it up and found that it was"a group or sect bound together by veneration of the same thing, person, ideal, etc." And when I admitted to him that I didnt know what it meant until I looked it up, he insulted hp fans because he was pretty sure that the series even mentioned the word cult at least once. So I made a deal with him, and now if he finds the word cult in the series (he's gonna re-read all the books) then i'll have to do something that he'll make up for me (like a dare almost) so now im nervous wondering if the word really IS in the series, so can anyone help me search for it? i'd really apreciate it! if anyone finds it tell me what book and what page :D thanks! have fun on ur mission!!! :)

 catsrule465 posted over a year ago
next question »

Harry Potter Answers

Cinders said:
First of all, there's no reason I can think of in the Harry Potter series for Rowling to use the word cult, except, potentially, about the Death Eaters, but even so. "Cult" seems like a Muggle concern more than anything else.

Secondly, your definition is accurate, but neglects to take into account all the negative connotations of the word. Also, cults tend to have charismatic leaders, forbid socializing with those outside the cult, and involve financial scams and, sometimes, suicide pacts. But those are real cults, like the Manson Family or the Heaven's Gate cult. The word "cult" is often thrown around as an insult to small social groups, generally fans of a popular topic. Harry Potter, Twilight, Lost, One Tree Hill - but fans of these things are NOT cults by a long shot. The term is just used as a hyperbolic insult.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
NCISLuverjk93 said:
I am 99.9% sure that in the whole Harry Potter series there is not the word 'Cult'... Sorry I can't be more helpful though! I will go look to be sure :P
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
thanks though :)!!!! i cant think of an instance where it would be used...
catsrule465 posted over a year ago
*
your welcome but yeah me either, I could picture Ron saying it about the death eaters but only in the movies lol
NCISLuverjk93 posted over a year ago
*
nice point, Vixie79. Even if there is the word cult in the series, it doesn't mean that the whole thing is a cult. It maybe telling us of how the Death Eaters worshipped Ol' Voldy. Besides, what right does he have to trample on the past time we love? Is is so wrong to like Harry's story?
MrSardonic22 posted over a year ago
bribee10 said:
Well, (no offense) but are you a boy? cuz its usually boys who make such stupid and spontaneous bets, and the like. well im pretty sure IT IS in the series, but im not sure what book or page. i think its used when describing the deatheaters. ex. deatheaters are a cult of muggle hating terrorists who work for Lord Voldamort...."
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
haha no im not a guy :P but im pretty sure i know my HP so i made this bet (+ he has told me that he doesnt like hp as much anymore, but i think if i he rereads the series then he'll love it just like i do :) so its almost a win-win
catsrule465 posted over a year ago
*
yeah, ur right. i made my mom reread the series cuz she said she liked it when she was my age, but me like her, wld grow out of it. i said i nvr wld and that she was to reread the books and then update me on her thoughts about it
bribee10 posted over a year ago
*
whos not a guy?
bribee10 posted over a year ago
luinwen said:
I'm not sure really, but I'm almost certain that no, the word cult is never used, the death eaters might be considered as a cult, but I don't remember no one actually saying the word cult
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
hey are you into Kingdom Hearts?
bribee10 posted over a year ago
*
thats sort of what i was thinking, but im still not 100% positive
catsrule465 posted over a year ago
*
are you into kingdom hearts?
bribee10 posted over a year ago
*
I know the game, but I've never played it, why?
luinwen posted over a year ago
volleyblue13 said:
I am almost absolutely sure that the word cult isn't mentioned in the Harry Potter series. In fact, I didn't know what a cult was until recently when someone called the Twilight fans a cult X)
select as best answer
I am almost absolutely sure that the word cult isn't mentioned in the Harry Potter series. In fact, I didn't know what a cult was until recently when someone called the Twilight fans a cult X)
posted over a year ago 
*
and btw, by what he's saying, basically any fandom is a cult.
volleyblue13 posted over a year ago
*
i keep hearing that word EVERYWHERE now; no joke :P
catsrule465 posted over a year ago
*
LMAO I love that picture!!
boolander25 posted over a year ago
Wenuhotep208 said:
When he says cult i think he means series.
usually i think of a cult as spiritual or governmetal .
besides harry potter and other fan series are fantasy,right their just the same as video games
only you watch things instead of play.

sincerely
Andrea
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
no u can have an object that u admire and form a cult around it--dictionary.com said so :P but hes very knowlegeable so i think he knows what hes talking about.
catsrule465 posted over a year ago
snusnu13 said:
I don't think so, I mean, I always thought Twilight fans were a cult, not HP fans.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
*
Dude, that wasn't even the question she asked. Why do you have to bring up Twilight???
Mrs-X posted over a year ago
*
because Twilight fans are a cult, I'm saying what a cult of fans are, which HP fans are not
snusnu13 posted over a year ago
_Lin_Bell_ said:
I've read every book and since I've never heard of the word cult I am about 99.9% sure it's not there. By the way, what happens if the word cult isn't there. Does your friend have to do something?
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
HarryRocks1996 said:
98 percent sure the word cult isnt in the HP series. 2 percent sure your being pariniod.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
pensatibo said:
I think that we are not a cult. we are just fans that like Harry potter. We read the books beacuse we find them interesting. I (in my opinion) am not part of a cult. Beacuse if I were i would have my profile full of pics. and other stuff. But i dont. If some poeple do Well that their profile. let them do what ever they want with it. Im soory for my words but in my opinion i think its the truth
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
Laruna said:
i am 100 percent sure that the word cult is not in the harry potter series. it was one of those words that all the overly zealous pta moms were searching for. its just not there anywhere. rowling avoided it like the plague methinks.
select as best answer
posted over a year ago 
next question »